With the 2011 NFL season in the books, it’s never
too early to look ahead to next year.
In what will be a multi-column article, I have attempted to rank the
NFL’s top 100 players heading into the 2012 season. It is my hope that at the conclusion of this I will accept
that football is over, at least for a few months, and that I will be ready to
write about other sports. But
until then…
This is not
a prediction of who will be the best player five years down the road from now
nor is it meant as a list of the players with the 100 best careers thus far
(Ray Lewis will not be in the top 10).
I’m not giving bonus points for previous Super Bowls and I’m not
reducing the value of players on underachieving teams. This list is not meant as a preview of
which players will have the best statistical seasons as ranking by this method
would make certain players rely heavily on others (a running back and his line,
a wide out and his quarterback).
In other words, a player’s position on this list would not change if he
were traded into a better or worse situation. The list simply answer’s the question, who are the league’s
100 best players?
In creating this hierarchy, I attempted to treat
all positions equally. However,
there’s just no way a team would ever trade the number 100 player on the list
for even the best kicker, punter, or long snapper in football. As such, no one
from said positions made the cut, although Sebastian Janikowski and Andy Lee
topped the kicker and punter positions respectively. Fifty-seven offensive players made the final list. There are 13 quarterbacks, 13 half
backs, one full back, 14 wide receivers, five tight ends, and 11 offensive
linemen. Two of the offensive
players who I selected were chosen, at least in part, for their special teams talents. The 43 defensive players were composed
of 16 linebackers, 15 defensive linemen, seven cornerbacks, and five
safeties.
Comparing players of different positions is nearly
impossible. I found the most
challenging aspect of this process to be correctly placing the offensive
linemen as well as the recent surge of defensive talent that has made its way
into the league over the last two seasons.
Creating this was as inexact as it was
opinion. Anything formulated under
these two pretenses should be seen as
a subject of debate. So… let the
debating begin.